Monday, February 14, 2011

Robert Pack Browning Opposes HB219 making 1911 Browning Pistol Utah State Firearm


A letter read to the House prior to their vote to approve the bill proposing  "state symbols and designations to designate the Browning model   M1911 automatic pistol as the state firearm", said that John M. Browning's brother’s great-grandson opposed the bill and the men who designed guns would be shocked.
Browning feels that as violence destroys so many lives and families it is inappropriate to glorify firearms by designating an “official state firearm.”
A KSL Dan Jones poll of 496 Utah residents found that only 37% approve the bill.  House voted 48-20 with seven absent, to approve the bill.
The Senate voted  20-7 with two absent to approve the bill.

What does this vote show about the Legislature representing their constituents in their voting?

HB219 Utah State Legislature

 SEQUENCE #144                    STATE OF UTAH                        HB 219  
                            HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES                   BY Wimmer
                  2011 General Session of the 59th Legislature                 
                                 VOTE TABULATION                               

                            State Firearm Designation                          
                                                                               
 FEBRUARY 11, 2011                                          Lockhart           
 10:26:25 AM                                                SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE
                                                                               
                                  Final Passage                                

 YEAS - 48

      Anderson          Galvez            Kiser             Powell           
      Barrus            Gibson            Last              Ray              
      Bird              Greenwood         Mathis            Sagers           
      Brown, M          Grover            Menlove           Sandstrom        
      Christensen       Handy             Morley            Sanpei           
      Clark             Harper            Newbold           Sumsion          
      Daw               Hendrickson       Noel              Vickers          
      Dee               Herrod            Oda               Webb             
      Draxler           Hughes            Perry             Wilcox            
      Duckworth, S      Hutchings         Peterson, J       Wiley            
      Dunnigan          Ipson             Peterson, V       Wilson           
      Froerer           Ivory             Pitcher           Wimmer           
 NAYS - 20

      Arent             Cosgrove          Hemingway         Poulson          
      Biskupski         Cox               King              Richardson       
      Briscoe           Edwards           Litvack           Seelig           
      Brown, D          Eliason           Moss              Watkins          
      Chavez-Houck      Fisher, Janice    Nielson           Wheatley         

 ABSENT OR NOT VOTING - 7

      Butterfield       Fisher, Julie     Painter           Lockhart         
      Dougall           McIff             Wright           


184
 
                                UTAH STATE SENATE                         
                                59th LEGISLATURE                          
                              2011 GENERAL SESSION                        
       
       HB 219                                                     RCS# 184
       PASSAGE ON THIRD                              2/10/2011 10:59:30 AM
       3rd Reading                                                        
       
                            State Firearm Designation                     
                                                                          
                                     Wimmer                               
       
  
                           20 YEAS   7 NAYS   2 ABSENT              PASSED
       
 
       YEAS 20

       
              Adams           Jenkins         Okerlund        Thatcher       
       Bramble         Knudson         Reid            Urquhart        
       Buttars         Liljenquist     Stephenson, H.  Valentine       
       Christensen     Madsen          Stevenson, J.   Van Tassell     
       Dayton          Niederhauser    Stowell         Waddoups        
       
      NAYS 7
       Davis           Mayne           Morgan          Romero          
       Jones           McAdams         Robles          
           
       ABSENT 2
       
       Hillyard        Hinkins         
       

No comments: